jabuci
My program eats up the memory and the OS kills it
I’m new to Elixir (started yesterday) and as a first little program, I wanted to solve the Münchausen numbers problem.
“A Münchausen number is a number equal to the sum of its digits raised to each digit’s power. For instance, 3435 is a Münchausen number because 3^3+4^4+3^3+5^5 = 3435. The largest Münchausen number is less than 440 million.”
The problem is that my program eats up all my RAM (16 GB) and the OS kills the process. And I don’t understand what goes on with the garbage collector.
Here is my solution:
#!/usr/bin/env elixir
defmodule Munchausen do
@cache [0] ++ for n <- 1..9, do: n ** n
def get_cache(), do: @cache
def explode(n), do: explode(n, [])
# int, acc -> list[int]
def explode(n, acc) when n == 0, do: acc
def explode(n, acc) do
digit = rem(n, 10)
explode(div(n, 10), [digit | acc])
end
# int -> bool
def is_munchausen(n) do
digits = explode(n)
li = for x <- digits, do: Enum.at(@cache, x)
n == Enum.sum(li)
end
end
defmodule Main do
# @max 10_000
@max 440_000_000
def main() do
# Munchausen.get_cache() |> IO.inspect
for n <- 0..@max do
# :erlang.garbage_collect()
if rem(n, 1_000_000) == 0 do
IO.puts("# #{n}")
end
if Munchausen.is_munchausen(n) do
IO.puts(n)
end
end
end
end
Main.main()
I know that it’s not optimal and slow. I’ll work on it.
Now the question is: why does it consume all my memory and how to prevent that? Thanks.
Marked As Solved
al2o3cr
A for loop like this will return a list containing the results of every evaluation of the do block:
for n <- 0..10 do
IO.puts(n)
end
Running this in iex produces:
iex(1)> for n <- 0..10 do
...(1)> IO.puts(n)
...(1)> end
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
[:ok, :ok, :ok, :ok, :ok, :ok, :ok, :ok, :ok, :ok, :ok]
Your Main.main function is building up a 440 million element list of :ok and nil, which it then discards when it exits.
Also Liked
tj0
Also, check out Memoize — memoize v1.4.0 , it makes the caching step trivial. For fibonnaci example:
defmodule Fib do
use Memoize
defmemo fibs(0), do: 0
defmemo fibs(1), do: 1
defmemo fibs(n), do: fibs(n - 1) + fibs(n - 2)
end
jabuci
Thanks. Right, the same thing happens in Python too:
$ python3
Python 3.10.4 (main, Mar 23 2022, 23:05:40) [GCC 11.2.0] on linux
>>> a = list(range(0, 440_000_000))
[1] 216403 killed python3
So what’s the solution? How to iterate over the numbers from 0 until 440 million?
Update: I found the answer to my question:
Enum.each(0..@max, fn n ->
if rem(n, 1_000_000) == 0 do
IO.puts("# #{n}")
end
if Munchausen.is_munchausen(n) do
IO.puts(n)
end
end)
kokolegorille
You might use stream to process the list lazily…







