WFransen

WFransen

[Question] KafkaEx - manually committing offsets

Hello,

I’m trying to manually commit offsets with KafkaEx. The following is present:

  • A topic: a-topic-which-has-a-lot-of-messages
  • A producer which produces messages (Protobuf encoded messages)
  • Following sample code:
Application.ex
# application.ex - ignoring boiler plate code
      consumer_opts = [fetch_options: [max_bytes: 2_000_000]]
      supervisor(
        KafkaEx.ConsumerGroup,
        [MyOwnFancyConsumer, "worker_consumer_group", ["a-topic-which-has-a-lot-of-messages"], consumer_group_opts]
      ),

Fun fact: in KafkaEx the default request max_bytes setting is 1_000_000 if i’m not mistaken. Since the default kafka topic batch message size was bigger than KafkaEx according to the docs, it failed with a rather cryptic error. Hence I’m setting the client max_bytes a lot higher. It would be nice if this would be the same as the Kafka default settings, but not complaining about small stuff here :wink:

Next up the MyOwnFancyConsumer module:
defmodule MyOwnFancyConsumer do
  use KafkaEx.GenConsumer

  alias KafkaEx.Protocol.Fetch
  alias KafkaEx.Protocol.Produce

  def handle_message_set(msg_set, state) do
    msg_set
    |> Enum.map(fn %Fetch.Message{value: message} = original_message ->
      {MyCompiledProtobufModuleMessage.decode!(message), original_message}
    end)
    |> Enum.each(fn {%MyCompiledProtobufModuleMessage{} = todo_task_message, original_message} ->
      # do some work

      my_offset_commit_request = %KafkaEx.Protocol.OffsetCommit.Request{
        offset: original_message.offset,
        partition: original_message.partition,
        topic: "a-topic-which-has-a-lot-of-messages"
      }

      # It crashes with the next line. Error log incoming after this code block
      tryresult = KafkaEx.offset_commit(self(), my_offset_commit_request)
    end)

    # I don't need to do this I guess... was wondering, could i just return a {:noreply, state} as with a GenServer?
    {:sync_commit, state}
  end
And at last the error (put it simply: genserver tries to call itself):
10:52:08.542 [error] GenServer #PID<0.261.0> terminating
** (stop) exited in: GenServer.call(#PID<0.261.0>, {:offset_commit, %KafkaEx.Protocol.OffsetCommit.Request{api_version: 0, consumer_group: nil, generation_id: -1, member_id: "kafkaex", metadata: "", offset: 0, partition: 0, timestamp: 0, topic: "a-topic-which-has-a-lot-of-messages"}}, 7000)
    ** (EXIT) process attempted to call itself
    ...
Last message: :timeout
State: %KafkaEx.GenConsumer.State{acked_offset: 0, api_versions: %{fetch: 0, offset_commit: 0, offset_fetch: 0}, auto_offset_reset: :none, commit_interval: 5000, commit_threshold: 100, committed_offset: 0, consumer_module: MyOwnFancyConsumer, consumer_state: nil, current_offset: 0, fetch_options: [auto_commit: false, worker_name: #PID<0.262.0>], generation_id: 3, group: "worker_consumer_group", last_commit: -576460722500, member_id: "kafka_ex-79e419a3-9991-4dc0-8102-6c0115f281e6", partition: 0, topic: "a-topic-which-has-a-lot-of-messages", worker_name: #PID<0.262.0>}

What works:

  • Process all the messages in batch and sync commit, so far for stream processing though… Don’t like this solution.
  • don’t manually commit and sync commit / async commit after batch
  • Adjusting kafka settings to put the max_bytes / message quite low, but don’t like this as well.

What doesn’t work (and why I’m writing this post) is to manually commit offsets. Couldn’t immediately find sample code / detailed documentation regarding this. Function isn’t documented at the docs as well. Is my way of thinking wrong to let the consumer manually commit its offset?

docker compose i'm using:
version: "3.3"

services:
  zookeeper_1:
    image: confluentinc/cp-zookeeper:latest
    container_name: zookeeper_1
    environment:
      ZOOKEEPER_SERVER_ID: 1
      ZOOKEEPER_CLIENT_PORT: 2181
      KAFKA_OPTS: "-Dzookeeper.4lw.commands.whitelist=*"

  kafka_1:
    image: confluentinc/cp-kafka:latest
    container_name: kafka_1
    depends_on:
      - zookeeper_1
    environment:
      KAFKA_BROKER_ID: 1
      KAFKA_ZOOKEEPER_CONNECT: zookeeper_1:2181
      KAFKA_ADVERTISED_LISTENERS: PLAINTEXT://localhost:9092
      KAFKA_OFFSETS_TOPIC_REPLICATION_FACTOR: 1
    ports:
      - "9092:9092"

Elixir and erlang version:

Erlang/OTP 23 [erts-11.0.2] [source] [64-bit] [smp:8:8] [ds:8:8:10] [async-threads:1] [hipe]

IEx 1.10.4 (compiled with Erlang/OTP 23)

kafka_ex version: 0.11

Thank you in advance.

Most Liked

keathley

keathley

Right, your message processing should all be idempotent.

The way we achieve this is by tagging each message with a globally unique id. We use https://github.com/keathley/hlcid for this but you could also use a flake id, uuidv4, etc. We assign these ids as early as we can. Each consumer can then use those ids to enforce its delivery semantics: at most once or at least once. For most operations we choose to use at least once semantics + idempotence to achieve exactly once delivery semantics. For scenarios where you guarantee idempotence (most commonly sending an RPC to a service you don’t control and can’t support at least once delivery) we have to use At Most Once delivery.

In order to achieve either of these schemes, you’ll need a way to store which ids you’ve already processed. If you need at most once processing, you can check to see if the id has already been stored and if it hasn’t you immediately store it, then proceed to do whatever action you need to take. If you end up replaying that message, either due to a crash, error, restart, something upstream re-published the message or some other transient failure, you’ll end up skipping the operation, even if the operation had previously failed.

If you want At Least Once processing, you check to see if the id is stored, do your work, and then store the id. This assumes that the operations that you’re conducting are also idempotent. For instance, incrementing a counter isn’t an idempotent operation. So, instead you’ll need to use something like a Set and add your id to the set. Then when you want the count you can take the cardinality of the Set.

I gave a talk on this a while ago: https://keathley.io/talks/kafka_the_hard_parts.html which might be useful. After working on these types of systems over the past few years, my opinion is that stream processing systems are incredibly fragile. We’ve spent a lot of time building internal libraries that support this stuff but unfortunately I haven’t been able to get them open sourced yet. IMO the ecosystem is really lacking a solid answer around kafka specifically. I think Elixir and Erlang are really well suited for data pipeline problems, but the tooling around kafka and other ingestion isn’t really there yet. If you need to do this for production you should be ready to support a lot of your own tooling. Otherwise you should probably just use kstreams, flink, wallaroo, storm, etc.

Where Next?

Popular in Questions Top

shahryarjb
Hello, I get Persian date from my client and convert it to normal calendar like this: def jalali_string_to_miladi_english_number(persi...
New
dotdotdotPaul
Okay, I'm having a heck of a time trying to figure out how to best handle the validation of belongs_to associations in Ecto. I'm sure I'...
New
gshaw
What is the idiomatic way of matching for not nil in Elixir? E.g., First way: defp halt_if_not_signed_in(conn, signed_in_account) when...
New
LegitStack
I’m hoping you guys can give me some general advice and perhaps code examples if you’re feeling up to it. I’m very interested in Elixir,...
New
openscript
Hello! Sorry for this astonishing simple question, but I’m really stuck. I try to set up the intellij-elixir plugin, but I don’t know ho...
New
New
lk-geimfari
What is most correct way to open, read and parse JSON file with poison? For example if we have example.json file in root of some projec...
New
stefanchrobot
What’s the safe way to decode a JSON string into a struct? I want to avoid calling String.to_atom. Jason.decode can give me a map with st...
New
gonzofish
I’m currently trying to understand how to join three tables using Ecto. All the examples I’ve seen use 2, so maybe I’m just missing somet...
New
beno
I will often find my self writing things similar to: case some_value do nil -&gt; something() "" -&gt; something() _ -&gt; someth...
New

Other popular topics Top

JDanielMartinez
Hi! May someone helps me, please! I have two apps into an umbrella project: the first one is Database, which manages queries, and the se...
New
shahryarjb
Hello, I get Persian date from my client and convert it to normal calendar like this: def jalali_string_to_miladi_english_number(persi...
New
vonH
In asking this question I am more interested about the expressiveness of the language itself and less concerned about the availability of...
New
New
polypush135
As many of you may have realized by now (sorry for all the posts here) I’ve been working on a db problem where I’m trying to aggregate a ...
New
nsuchy
Hi. I’ve noticed that Windows Powershell has it’s own IEX command and you cannot access Elixir’s IEX due to the conflict. This isn’t a cr...
New
alice
Hey, Just curious what are the main benefits of Elixir compared to Clojure? When is Elixir more useful than Clojure and vice versa? Th...
New
stefanluptak
Hello everybody, usually, I use a 29" ultra-wide monitor for VSCode which can easily accomodate explorer (files panel) + file with code ...
New
TunkShif
This post is an instruction guide to help you setup your Neovim for Elixir development from scratch. It includes general information on h...
273 38985 115
New
AstonJ
We’ve put together this wiki for Phoenix LiveView - please feel free to add any info you feel is worth including. What is Phoenix LiveV...
New

We're in Beta

About us Mission Statement